Is this normal, or kind of a jerk move?

DaleB

New member
After joining the flying club and my last CFI being gone for two weeks, I've started flying with a CFI who is also a club member. This avoids some insurance and paperwork hassles, his availability matches mine better, and he's got a lot of experience instructing. My last guy had me do touch & gos for something like 7 hours solid before finally signing me off for solo flying. So I'm flying a 172 now instead of Cherokees, and it looks like we'll be finishing up over the next couple of weeks.

Tonight we were going to knock out the dual X/C, dual night and dual night landings in one shot. As it happens we made a no-go call due to weather. No biggie. But as we're at the FBO going over the route and all, my last CFI shows up. We say hello, etc. He asks if I'll be flying with my new CFI from now on, I tell him yes. He asks to see my logbook. I was busy with other stuff and kind of wondered why, but slid it down the counter. Next thing I know, he's scratched out the PA-28 solo endorsement on my medical and voided the solo endorsements he signed in the back of my logbook.

To borrow a phrase from Captain... is this guy a jerk? Or is that something that's common? Kind of ****ed me off, to be honest. My current CFI kind of looked puzzled and wondered why the hell he'd have done that, said he'd never heard of it.
 
For what it is worth, Advisory Circular 61-65E says this about endorsements:
"Although section 61.19(b) establishes, in a pertinent part, that a student pilot certificate expires 24 calendar-months from the month in which it is issued, the endorsements on that student pilot certificate are a matter of record indefinitely. The endorsements are required to be updated from “time-to-time” in the student pilot’s logbook to retain solo privileges."
 
Found this old Q&A with Rod Machado on this subject: http://flighttraining.aopa.org/magazine/2003/October/200310_Commentary_Since_You_Asked.html
Dear Rod,
I am a newly minted CFI and feel I may have screwed up by endorsing a student. [...] Should I cancel his endorsement, and if so how should I go about doing so? Can I just write VOID over it like a check, or is there an FAA-approved way to do it? [...]
Greetings Carl:
[...] First, there's no convenient way for you to rescind a solo endorsement other than tearing it out of his logbook. [...]
Well at least he didn't take Machado's advice literally and tear the page out of your logbook!
 
Back
Top